Showing posts with label SEC. Show all posts
Showing posts with label SEC. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 8, 2008

SEC finds deficiencies in credit rating processes of Fitch, Moody's and S&P.

A few weeks back, this blog had talked about a proposal by the SEC to regulate the credit rating industry. In addition to this proposal, the SEC today released the findings of an investigation into the rating procedures followed by by 3 major credit rating agencies (Fitch, S&P and Moody's). Some very disturbing facts have come to light at the conclusion of this investigation:

1.The SEC staff's examinations found that rating agencies struggled significantly with the increase in the number and complexity of subprime residential mortgage-backed securities (RMBS) and collateralized debt obligations (CDO) deals since 2002.

2. None of the rating agencies examined had specific written comprehensive procedures for rating RMBS and CDOs.

3. Significant aspects of the rating process were not always disclosed or even documented by the firms, and conflicts of interest were not always managed appropriately.

4. The internal audit processes followed at these firms varied substantially.Out of the 3 credit rating agencies, only one had adequate internal audit processes and management follow up. Out of the other 2, one had an inadequate one page check list kind of an audit that appeared inadequate and the other agency's internal audit resulted in plenty of critical findings but were never acted upon by the management.

5. Significant aspects of the ratings process were not always disclosed

6.The rating agencies did not always document significant steps in the ratings process - including the rationale for deviations from their models and for rating committee actions and decisions - and they did not always document significant participants in the ratings process.

The investigation also had access to emails and other communication between analysts at these firms. In one exchange, dated April 5, 2007, an analyst said the ratings model didn't capture "half" of the deal's risk but that "it could be structured by cows and we would rate it," according to the report.

With a virtual collapse of its internal control system(computer 'glitches', weak internal audits, conflicts of interest, inadequate documentation of the rating process coupled with zero public disclosure), it's a wonder there is even a shred of confidence left in the ratings produced by these three credit rating agencies. The SEC plans to take up a similar investigation for another seven agencies in the next few months.

Sunday, June 29, 2008

SEC regulatory proposal for Credit Rating Agencies.




After a tumultous year or two in the financial markets, finally some regulatory action. In mid June, the SEC invited comments to a planned proposal to reduce the influence of credit rating agencies (CRA) in the financial markets. The central theme of such a proposal is 'to address concerns about the integrity of their credit rating procedures and methodologies in the light of the role they played in determining credit ratings for securities collateralized by or linked to subprime residential mortgages' No surprises there... Following the recent market turmoil (everybody's favorite phrase),the Senate Banking Committee held a hearing on the role of the credit rating agencies in the mortgage mess. They directed that the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) impose tough regulations on the rating industry.

The SEC plans to propose new rules that would be aimed at enhancing disclosure, comparability as well as provide more detailed information on the processes and methodologies behind the credit ratings. These rules would also add reporting requirements and address conflicts of interest that may arise in the structured products rating process.

According to the Wall Street Journal, the SEC will propose new rules that may 'diminish the importance of credit ratings in determining the amount of capital that investment banks are required to hold'. Floyd Norris of the New York Times, says that credit rating agencies are being made the scapegoats in a crisis that seems to have no end to it. Besides rating agencies, weak regulations that let borrowers with poor credit history borrow money are also to blame.

While that may be true, lets not forget Moody's credit rating 'computer glitches' reported by the Financial Times a few weeks back followed by a 'confession' by S&P reporting its own rating 'glitch'.



Friday, April 4, 2008

SEC support to Basel Committee.

In the light of the recent financial market turmoil, the Basel Committee's Working Group on Liquidity has planned some key updates to their liquidity management guidelines for banks.

Mr. Christopher Cox, chairman of the SEC recently wrote to Dr. Wellink, chairman of the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision. Although the objective of the letter was to express support for upcoming updates in the guidance for liquidity management, yet the bulk of the letter addressed the Bear Stearns collapse. It attributed the collapse to rumours and a 'self fulfilling prophecy' than inadequate liquidity management.

Mr. Cox provided the capital and liquidity position of Bear Stearns prior to and up to the days leading to the take over by J P Morgan Chase. It showed the liquidity pool on Jan 31 up until March 13th. Mr.Cox remarks how the liquidity pool of Bear Stearns diminished from $18 billion on Mar 10th to $2 billion on March 13th which resulted in Bear's collapse.
Interestingly, towards the beginning of the year (Jan 31st) the liquidity pool stood at only $8 billion.

According to Mr.Cox, although Bear Stearns' holding company and the bank's 2 SEC registered brokerage dealers had adequate capital to fulfill the Basel II standards, yet "evaporation of market confidence" led to liquidity being impaired.

An obvious question that comes to mind is: how did the current regulatory structure at SEC miss this impending debacle? By reassuring the Basel Committee about the adequacy of Bear's capital structure, the SEC has failed to answer a very important question which is how did the bank crumble in spite of such an apparently strong capital position? Does the SEC truly believe that rumor mongers and market whispers were the sole reason for Bear's downfall?
Innovative financial products fared very well in an unregulated market. But their failure also meant the crumbling failure of the biggest financial markets and consequently a weakening in the economy.

It will be interesting to see how Treasury Secretary Mr.Paulson's plans to overhaul the financial regulatory environment actually plays out in the coming months.